Parking Map 
Top 10 Dont's When Buying An Engagement Ring
November 6th, 2015
Top 10 Engagement Ring Mistakes
And How to Avoid Them
Expert advice from Smith's Jewelers in Noblesville, IN — before you make one of the biggest purchases of your life.
Buying an engagement ring is one of the biggest purchases you'll ever make — and it's easy to make costly mistakes if you don't know what to look for.
At Smith's Jewelers in Noblesville, IN, we help customers navigate engagement ring shopping every day. Here are the ten most common mistakes we see — and exactly how to avoid each one.
Quick Summary: Set a realistic budget, consider alternative gemstones, focus on your partner's style, compare multiple stores, avoid buying online without seeing the ring in person, insure your ring immediately, balance size with quality, plan for production time, confirm the correct ring size, and shop local for better service and value.
Don't Expect to Pay Next to Nothing for an Engagement Ring
Set a realistic budget before you start shopping. Most engagement rings cost significantly more than people expect, especially for larger or higher-quality diamonds.
At Smith's Jewelers in Noblesville, we often see customers come in expecting a 2-carat diamond for a very low price. In reality, diamond pricing depends heavily on quality factors like cut, clarity, and color — and a quality stone at that size carries a significant price tag.
The best move is to save intentionally and set a budget before you walk into any store. If you need help, most jewelers — including Smith's — offer layaway and financing options. We provide a 10-month layaway program and 12-months interest-free financing to make your purchase as manageable as possible. Ask about financing options when you visit.
Don't Assume the Center Stone Has to Be a Diamond
Gemstone engagement rings are a beautiful, budget-friendly alternative — but make sure you understand the durability of the stone before purchasing.
Think outside the box. Sapphires, morganites, and other gemstones make stunning center stones and often come in at a lower price point than diamonds of comparable size. Gemstone engagement rings have surged in popularity in recent years for exactly this reason.
One important consideration: gemstones are softer than diamonds and will scratch or chip more easily over time. All stones are rated on the Mohs hardness scale — the higher the number, the more resistant to abrasion. Ask our team about the durability of any gemstone you're considering so you can make a confident, informed purchase.
Don't Forget Who You're Actually Shopping For
It's easy to fall in love with what you like — keep your partner's taste at the center of every decision.
This one sounds obvious, but it happens constantly. Shoppers get wrapped up in their own preferences and drift away from what their partner actually loves. If you're unsure of their style, check their Pinterest board — it's one of the most reliable windows into exactly what they'd want on their finger.
Pay attention to the jewelry they already wear. Do they lean toward classic and simple, or bold and detailed? Yellow gold or white gold? Vintage-inspired or modern? These cues will guide you far better than your own taste ever could.
Don't Shop Just One Store
Compare your options before committing. Local independent jewelers often offer better quality, better pricing, and a more personal experience than large chain stores.
It's tempting to walk into the biggest mall store, make a decision, and be done with it. But comparing a few stores — especially local jewelers — almost always reveals better value. At Smith's Jewelers in Noblesville, we regularly have customers tell us they found a higher-quality ring at a lower price than what the national chains quoted them.
Local jewelers also offer something the chains can't: a personal relationship. When you buy from a local store, you're building a connection with experts who will be there for sizing, cleaning, repairs, and future purchases for years to come. Visit us and see the engagement ring selection for yourself.
Don't Buy an Engagement Ring Online Without Seeing It First
Photos don't capture how a diamond actually looks in person. See it, touch it, and let an experienced jeweler guide you before you buy.
Online ring shopping is convenient, but it comes with real risks. A diamond that looks brilliant on a screen can appear dull, lifeless, or poorly proportioned in person — and returning an engagement ring is a stressful experience nobody wants. Cut quality, proportions, and how light interacts with a stone are things you genuinely cannot evaluate from a photograph.
The best way to buy the perfect ring is in a store where you can physically see it and compare it side by side with other options. Let experienced sales professionals at a trusted local jewelry store help you find the right ring at the right price. You'll walk out confident.
Don't Forget to Insure the Ring Immediately
Have the ring insured as soon as possible after purchase. A detailed appraisal — usually provided free with purchase — is all you need to get it added to your policy.
You've found the ring, you've proposed, and she said yes. Now what? Get it insured. Life is unpredictable — rings get lost, stolen, or damaged — and an uninsured ring is an unprotected investment.
Contact your insurance provider and ask them to add the ring to your homeowner's or renter's policy. You'll need a detailed jewelry appraisal to do this, which should have been provided at the time of purchase. If you didn't receive one, call the store — appraisals are typically free with purchase. Don't skip this step.
Bigger Isn't Always Better — Quality Matters Too
A smaller, higher-quality diamond will look more brilliant than a large, low-quality one. Learn the 4 C's before you shop.
Nearly everyone wants the biggest diamond possible. But a large diamond with poor cut, low clarity, or a yellowish tint can look flat and dull — while a smaller diamond with excellent cut and color can be absolutely breathtaking. Brilliance comes from quality, not just size.
The 4 C's — cut, color, clarity, and carat — all play a role in how a diamond looks. Cut is arguably the most important factor: a well-cut diamond returns light in a way that makes it sparkle intensely. If you need help understanding what you're looking at, ask to speak with our in-store gemologist. That's exactly what they're here for.
Don't Be Surprised If You Can't Take the Ring Home That Day
Many rings — especially custom or special-order pieces — require 2 to 4 weeks. Plan your purchase around your proposal date.
If you've fallen in love with a ring that needs to be special-ordered, sized precisely, or custom-built around a specific diamond, plan for two to four weeks of production time. This is normal — and it actually benefits you. Having a mounting built to the exact dimensions of your diamond and your partner's finger size protects the integrity of the ring and reduces the risk of side stones loosening over time.
Don't let the timeline catch you off guard. Visit us at Smith's Jewelers in Noblesville well before your planned proposal date so there's no rush and no stress. Browse our engagement ring collection to get started.
Don't Forget to Find Out Their Ring Size
If the ring needs to be sized more than two sizes up or down from stock, it's best to special-order it in the correct size from the start.
This is one of the most overlooked details in the buying process. Getting the finger size right — or as close as possible — before purchase saves you time, protects the ring, and keeps side stones from loosening during a significant resize later.
If you can't find out the size discreetly, borrow a ring she already wears on that finger and bring it in — our jewelers can measure it accurately. Most ring sizing in Noblesville can be done after the fact, but starting close to the right size is always the better path.
Don't Forget to Shop Local
Local jewelers offer better value, genuine expertise, and a long-term relationship that big-box stores simply can't match.
When you choose to shop local, you're not just buying a ring — you're investing in your community and building a relationship with experts who will know your name, your story, and your jewelry for years to come. Local businesses like Smith's Jewelers keep dollars in Hamilton County, support local employment, and create the kind of community character that makes Noblesville worth living in.
Before you head to a mall chain or a national retailer, stop into Smith's Jewelers on the Square. The service, quality, and pricing you'll find here are genuinely hard to match. We'd love to be part of your story.
Ready to Find the Perfect Ring?
Visit Smith's Jewelers in downtown Noblesville to explore engagement rings in person, or work with our team to design a custom piece. We'll help you avoid every one of these mistakes and find something truly special.