Parking Map 
Custom Jewelry in Noblesville, IN
At Smith's Jewelers in Noblesville, we design and build custom jewelry from the ground up — in-house, one piece at a time. Every project starts with your idea, whether that's a fully formed design or just a starting point. We work with you to turn that into a finished piece that fits exactly what you're looking for.
Our custom work is completed in our on-site Smith's Workshop, which means your piece never leaves the building. From concept to completion, you're working directly with the people creating your jewelry.
From selecting the right materials to refining the final design, we guide you through each step so the finished piece reflects your style, your story, and exactly what you had in mind.
What We Create
Our workshop handles the full range of custom jewelry — from a single pendant built around a family stone to a completely original engagement ring designed collaboratively from scratch. If you can describe it, we can build it.
Custom Engagement Rings
The most personal piece of jewelry you'll ever wear deserves to be exactly right. We work with you to design a one-of-a-kind engagement ring — your choice of setting style, metal, stone shape, and every detail in between.
Custom Wedding Bands
From simple and classic to intricately patterned, we craft wedding bands that complement your engagement ring or stand beautifully on their own. Matching sets available for couples.
Heirloom Redesigns
Inherited jewelry that doesn't fit your style doesn't have to sit in a box. We can dismantle, melt down, and rebuild your existing pieces into something you'll actually wear — preserving the material and the meaning.
Custom Pendants & Necklaces
Commemorative pendants, birthstone necklaces, family crests, or completely original designs — our craftsmen build custom necklaces and pendants with the same precision as any other commission.
Memorial & Milestone Pieces
Marking a birth, a loss, an anniversary, or a personal achievement — we create jewelry designed to hold specific meaning. These are among the most personal pieces we make, and we treat them as such.
Anniversary & Gift Jewelry
Can't find the right gift? Design it. We work with customers on custom bracelets, rings, earrings, and other pieces built specifically around the recipient — their taste, their story, their style.
Where to Start
Bring your sketches, inspiration photos, existing jewelry, or even just an idea. During your first visit, we'll talk through your concept, look at materials, and give you a clear direction on what's possible and what the next steps look like.
Our process starts with a conversation, where we listen to your thoughts and guide you through the design possibilities. From choosing the perfect stones to selecting the right metals, we'll help refine your vision into a piece that captures your style and story.
Visit our store on the Square in Noblesville, sit with our designers, and let's begin creating something beautiful — one step at a time. Your dream design is closer than you think.
Can You Use My Existing Jewelry?
Yes — and this is one of our most requested services. If you have gold, diamonds, or gemstones from inherited pieces, old rings you no longer wear, or jewelry that holds sentimental value but not wearable style, we can work with what you have.
Bring in your piece for a free evaluation and we'll walk you through the options with no obligation.
The Custom Design Process
Every custom piece follows the same foundation — a clear, collaborative process designed to make sure the final result is exactly what you envisioned.
Consultation
Come in and talk with us. No sketch required. Bring inspiration images, a description, or just an idea. We listen first and advise second.
Design
We develop your concept into a design — a rendering, a wax model, or a detailed plan — and refine it with you before a single cut is made.
Fabrication
Your piece is built by hand in our Noblesville workshop by our own master craftsmen — not shipped to an outside vendor. Every step happens here.
Delivery
We review the finished piece together before it leaves the workshop. You see it, wear it, and confirm it's right before the job is done.
Why Choose Smith's for Custom Jewelry?
Custom jewelry requires a craftsman you can trust completely — with your vision, your stones, and sometimes your most meaningful possessions. Here's what makes Smith's the right choice in Noblesville.
We don't outsource. Your piece is designed and fabricated in our own workshop by our own team — not sent to a vendor in another city.
Our master craftsmen — including Brian Roll with 40 years and Steve Stadick with 35 years — bring a depth of skill that most local jewelers simply can't match.
Walk into our workshop, shake hands with the craftsman, and know exactly who is responsible for your jewelry. That accountability matters.
Your first consultation is free. You're never obligated to proceed, and we don't have commission targets that make us push you toward a decision.
If the first design isn't perfect, we refine it. You don't get one shot at this — we work together until the piece is right before fabrication begins.
We've been on the Square in Noblesville for decades. We're not a pop-up or an online-only shop. You can walk back in anytime your piece needs attention.
Serving Noblesville and the Surrounding Area
Our custom jewelry studio is in downtown Noblesville at 98 N 9th Street on the Square. We work with customers from across Hamilton County and central Indiana — including those looking for a custom jewelry designer near me who actually does the work locally.
- Fishers, IN — South on SR-37
- Carmel, IN — Via Keystone Pkwy or US-31
- Westfield, IN — Down SR-32
- Indianapolis, IN — Worth the drive for fully custom work
- Cicero & Arcadia, IN — Northern Hamilton County
- Zionsville, IN — Easy access via US-421
Frequently Asked Questions
How long does custom jewelry take to make?
We typically quote custom jewelry projects at up to two weeks to start, depending on the design and materials involved. More complex pieces — such as fully custom engagement rings or detailed heirloom redesigns — may take longer. We'll give you a clear and realistic timeline after your consultation.
If you're working with a deadline, let us know — we're always happy to consider rush requests whenever possible.
How much does custom jewelry cost?
Custom jewelry pricing varies based on the metal, stones, complexity, and labor involved. We don't have a minimum spend, and we work across a wide range of budgets. The best way to understand cost is to come in for a consultation — we'll be straightforward about what's achievable at your price point.
Can I bring in my own stones or metals?
Yes. We regularly work with customer-supplied diamonds, colored stones, and precious metals. If you have stones from inherited jewelry or a previous ring you'd like to incorporate, bring them in and we'll evaluate them and discuss your options.
Can you redesign or repurpose inherited jewelry?
Absolutely — this is one of our most common custom requests. We can melt down and rebuild existing gold, reset stones into new settings, or incorporate design elements from the original piece into something new. Bring in the piece for a free assessment and we'll walk you through what's possible.
Do I need a sketch or design idea to get started?
No. Many of our customers come in with nothing more than a vague sense of what they want — a feeling, a color, an occasion. We're experienced at drawing out ideas through conversation. Inspiration photos, Pinterest boards, or even a description of someone's personality are all valid starting points.
What's the difference between custom and semi-custom jewelry?
Semi-custom means modifying an existing design — changing the metal, adding stones, altering proportions. Fully custom means starting from a blank page with no predefined template. We offer both. If you've seen something close to what you want and just need it adjusted, that's often faster and more cost-effective than a full custom build.
Can I make changes during the design process?
Yes, within reason. The design phase is specifically meant for iteration — we expect revisions and build that expectation into our process. Changes become more difficult (and potentially costly) once fabrication has begun, so we make sure you're confident in the design before we start cutting metal.